# AI User Panel report: indiecru.sh

> Full panel · overall score 56/100 · https://www.indiecru.sh/report/el3PDuPufpENSe3gbJkIM

AI users are simulated personas, not real people. This report shows where they got stuck on indiecru.sh, with the exact step and their stated reason.

## Outcome

3 of 3 AI users completed the flow ("Sign up for an account and create a first project").

## Top issues

### Zero value proposition — 'a tiny demo app' is the entire product pitch (critical)
- Priya, impression
- Diane, impression
- Alex, impression
- Jordan, impression
- Rosa, impression

### Pricing, features, and /signup pages all return 404, making pre-signup evaluation impossible (critical)
- Priya, impression
- Diane, impression
- Alex, impression
- Sam, impression
- Ingrid, impression
- Jordan, impression
- Rosa, impression

### No privacy policy or terms of service linked on the signup form (critical)
- Ingrid, impression
- Diane, impression

### Email verification interrupt breaks momentum mid-onboarding (major)
- Nadia, step 4
- Henrik, step 4
- Carla, step 4

### Low-contrast form labels and invisible input borders fail WCAG AA (major)
- Sam, impression

### No social proof, trust signals, or 'made by' attribution anywhere on the signup page (major)
- Jordan, impression
- Rosa, impression
- Diane, impression

### No keyboard focus indicators or screen-reader hints on the form (minor)
- Sam, impression

### No password requirements or helper text shown before submission (minor)
- Sam, impression

## Quick wins

- Rewrite the subtitle to one concrete benefit sentence and delete the phrase 'tiny demo app' from all pages (< 5 minutes).
- Add a 'Terms of Service | Privacy Policy' footer line to the signup card — even placeholder pages are better than nothing (< 30 minutes).
- Remove or redirect broken nav links (/pricing, /features, /signup) to a 'Coming soon' page or back to the fixture URL so they stop returning 404 (< 15 minutes).
- Add visible input borders (1px solid #555) and fix label contrast in CSS — two property changes (< 10 minutes).
- Add :focus-visible outline styles globally in one CSS rule (< 5 minutes).

---
Generated by IndieCru.sh — AI users test your app before real ones see it. Free roast: https://indiecru.sh/roast